4 ways to deal with criticism (because everybody’s got an opinion.)

dealing with critics

I’m out of town this week at Blog World Expo, so I’m bringing you a post I wrote last summer after facing some criticism on my blog. I thought you might enjoy reading it now. Hope you’re having a lovely week!

Last night, as the evening was winding down, a flurry of extremely harsh comments came through on a couple of my posts about hiring help.

If you’re a writer, perhaps you understand the sick feeling of being misunderstood and accused of being a person you know you are not. And so perhaps you also understand my immediate reaction, which was to fire off a couple of terse responses.

After that, I took the dog for a walk. (I should have done this in reverse order, but nobody’s perfect.)

I spent the first ten minutes of the walk sputtering and composing scathing responses in my head, all the way to the bluff downtown that overlooks Lake Michigan. When I got there, I came to a full stop – body and mind – and just stared at the orange and gray twilight over Lake Michigan. When I finally turned away from the water and started heading for home, my mind was much quieter. And that’s when this simple thought popped into my head: “Has this person earned the right to shake my peace?”

And the answer, of course, was a resounding “no.”

How silly that, while the vast majority of the nearly 300 comments in those two threads were kind and respectful, I’d allowed somebody who represented a teeny, tiny minority to get under my skin. Somebody I don’t even know. Isn’t it funny how one negative comment or reaction has a way of looming larger in your psyche than dozens or perhaps hundreds of positive, encouraging, supportive messages? For instance:

  • You’re feeling really good about your parenting lately – the kids have been so well-behaved even the grumpy lady at church smiled at them on Sunday. Then the cashier at the grocery store makes a comment about you “bribing” your kids when you reward them with a package of fruit snacks. Suddenly you feel deflated, and your recent success feels like a fraud.
  • You’ve decided to start a business selling your crafts on Etsy. You sell a few items and have a small waiting list and lots of positive comments, and you’re feeling pretty good until…somebody you don’t even know makes fun of one of your creations on Twitter. Now you’re wondering if you should just close up shop and quit.
  • You got accepted to the nursing program at your local college – woohoo! At a family birthday party everyone congratulates you and you’re even the star of a celebratory toast. Then your great-aunt Edna asks how you can stand the idea of leaving your poor kids behind to go to work (the way she makes it sound, you’ll be throwing them into a closet with a few crusts of bread and a chamber pot.) Suddenly all those warm fuzzies are weighed down by a blanket of cold, prickly indignation, guilt and self-doubt.

It’s only natural to feel deflated in the face of criticism: being human, of course a good dousing in cold water affects us. The question is, how do we harness our healthy human vulnerability (the kind Brené Brown talks about) to make us better people and to help us be more courageous and kind, instead of either cowering in the corner or becoming hardened?

I don’t think there’s anything particularly virtuous in being so thick-skinned that harsh criticism and name-calling don’t sting. In fact, I think the expectation that we should be able to buck up and withstand nasty-grams from attackers without feeling the blow is really messed up. Frankly, I don’t ever want to be that desensitized.

On the other hand…

We also owe it to ourselves not to allow criticism to totally derail us. I think an initial reaction of irritation, indignation and even anger is totally normal, but after letting yourself “go there” you have to take a big step back and look at the situation objectively. Otherwise you risk playing a losing game and getting mired down in negativity.

Here are a few questions I ask myself when I’m feeling particularly rattled by other people’s criticism:

  1. Is the person being kind and respectful? If so, I’ll listen to what they have to say even if I don’t necessarily like it. If they’re nasty, unkind, or abusive, they’ve automatically disqualified themselves as people whose opinions I respect.
  2. Are the critics trusted sources? In other words, are these people who – by knowing me and caring about me, or by presenting a respectful argument – have earned the right to get my attention? Or are they taking cheap shots, criticizing without helping, or complete strangers who just blew in to start a fight?
  3. Is this really about me? Sometimes people have a bee in their bonnets about something and you’re just the closest target. And some people are so bent on getting a rise out of somebody that they’ll lash out until they hit any target. You won’t win no matter how many holes you poke in their logic and no matter how hard you try to prove that you really aren’t a jerk…because arguing is sport for them. It’s not personal, no matter how personal they make it seem.
  4. What do the numbers say? If five of my family members love what I made for dinner and one of them complains, I figure he’s the one with the faulty tastebuds. If all six of them can barely choke down my quinoa salad, perhaps it’s time to cross that dish off of the meal plan. It doesn’t mean I’m a bad person, by the way; just that this one thing I tried didn’t work.

Whether you’re chasing a dream, sharing your deepest feelings in a blog, or just trying to get through the day with kids, you’re going to encounter criticism. Sometimes it’s going to come from a place of loving concern, and sometimes…not so much. Either way it’s not easy to take. Give yourself a big break if you (like I did last night) initially over-react. You’re human. It’s natural to be hurt when people don’t seem to like you or support you.

But don’t let it keep you down. Chase the dream anyway. Write about your feelings anyway. Go out in public with your imperfect kids anyway, and bribe them with fruit snacks if you feel the need, even if that nosy cashier is watching. In the end, there’s a very small number of people to whom you have anything to prove, and you’re right at the top of that list.

Have you ever let a dream or decision get derailed by criticism? How do you deal when somebody doesn’t seem to like what you’re doing?

New to The Happiest Mom? Check out some of my most talked-about posts, and subscribe if you don’t want to miss a thing!

About The Author

57 Comments

  1. MKP
    • Meagan Francis
      • MKP
  2. Jill @BabyRabies
  3. The Mom Pledge
    • Meagan Francis
  4. Kathleen
  5. TheFeministBreeder
    • Meagan Francis
  6. All Fooked Up
  7. Catherine
    • Leah
  8. rebecca
    • TheFeministBreeder
    • Meagan Francis
      • Rebecca
    • SleeplessinSummerville
      • Meagan Francis
  9. Sarah
  10. Michelle
  11. Ana White
  12. Sarah
  13. Hands Free Mama
  14. JM
  15. the muskrat
  16. Susan
  17. Emily
    • Meagan Francis
  18. Lisa
  19. Meagan Francis
  20. Katya
  21. Missy | The Literal Mom
  22. Kathryn Sanchez
  23. Diana LoChiatto
  24. June
  25. Carrie
  26. Emily
  27. Amy @ Frugal Mama
  28. Jules
  29. Artsnark
  30. Wendy
  31. sleeplessinsummerville
  32. cagey
  33. Amber
  34. lil
  35. Becca
  36. Christine Balch
  37. Alexandria
  38. oilandgarlic
  39. Imogen
  40. Tommie
  41. woothemes